The idea sounded beautiful and outwardly appeared socially significant. Imagine: across the boundless Kazakh steppe a train is moving, in whose carriages, instead of reserved seats, medical offices are equipped: ultrasound, cardiologist, therapist, laboratory. For residents of remote auls, who need half a day to reach the nearest decent clinic, this, it seemed, created convenience — the doctors themselves come to them.
“Health Train” Without Passengers
In order for the mobile medical trains to actually operate, state structures paid for them using funds from the guaranteed volume of free medical care and the Fund of Compulsory Social Medical Insurance.
It was precisely here, where money is paid for each service that must be confirmed in a report, that a gap appeared into which Boris Chen slipped. The 53-year-old andrologist owned private medical clinics — LLP “Panacea Clinic” and LLP “Astana Clinic,” and from the inside knew how payment for medical services is arranged. Participation in the mobile medical train project in the period 2022–2025 became for him not only a business opportunity but also, as the court showed, a profitable startup, a way to earn money by fraudulent means.
In order to receive money from the medical insurance fund, there must be information about the services rendered, patients who underwent examination by a doctor, and data about this entered into the database. However, there turned out to be fewer patients in the carriages than was required for attractive reporting. Thus the plan arose to “close” the difference.
According to the investigation and the court’s findings, Chen instructed his subordinates to engage in mass falsifications. The verdict states that “in the period from 26 April 2023 to December 2024, while in the city of Astana, he committed fraud aimed at the illegal acquisition of monetary funds of the non-profit joint-stock company ‘Fund of Social Medical Insurance’ on an especially large scale.
Thus, B.G. Chen, reliably knowing the procedure for financing medical organizations within the framework of the GVFMC and CSMS, using the mobile medical train project, through subordinate employees organized the entry of knowingly false information into the medical information system ‘MedElement’ about the fictitious provision of medical services to persons to whom such services were not actually provided.”
In Order to Achieve the Criminal Intent
Having obtained information about real citizens, employees entered into the databases the surnames and IINs of people who had not taken tests and had never seen the train doctors: “In order to achieve the criminal intent, Chen ensured the formation and submission of forged applications through operators, where each operator entered into the system according to an approved plan from 90 to 150 patients per day. The volume of medical care provided to the population was artificially increased.”
But such schemes live only until the first careful verification. An in-depth check revealed discrepancies between the declared services and reality, and the scheme, as lawyers say, “came to the surface.”
At the end of 2025, Boris Chen was arrested. The charge: fraud.
In court he admitted that “lists of the attached population were searched for by the doctors on his instructions. For the same purpose he gave instructions to the senior doctor of the train A.E. All monetary operations were carried out by the accountant on his instructions.”
So, “ghost people” received services on paper, and the money paid for them went to accounts under his control. As a result of these machinations, damage in the amount of 682 million tenge was caused to the Medical Insurance Fund. These are funds that should have been used to treat people, not to pay for invented appointments. 682,971,948 tenge. Easily settled in his pocket…
Men at the Gynecologist
Operators entered the data without delving into its meaning. Thus, in their reports information appeared that men underwent cervical cancer screening. This caused far from cheerful jokes on social networks. In the verdict, these facts are stated as follows: “Conclusions on the quality and volume of the fictitious services rendered by LLP ‘Astana Clinic’ and LLP ‘Panacea Clinic,’ according to which violations were identified, for example, such as the provision of women’s services to persons of the male sex.”
As they say, both laughter and sin: in remote auls, doctors diagnosed and treated uterine cancer and other gynecological diseases… in men!
What won’t one do for the sake of a report and the material well-being of the boss, who, as was stated in court, put up to 100 million tenge into his pocket for one trip.
In the course of covert investigative actions, correspondence between doctors and operators was obtained, confirming the facts of falsification of medical services on the mobile medical train that were not actually provided to the population.
Therefore, in court it was unequivocally recognized: “the actions of the defendant were intentional in nature, were aimed at the illegal receipt of monetary funds of the Fund by reflecting unreliable information about the provision of medical services, which entailed the infliction of material damage on an especially large scale. Thus, the actions of the defendant Chen B.G. are subject to qualification under paragraph 2) of part 4 of Article 190 of the Criminal Code as fraud, that is, the theft of another’s property committed by deception on an especially large scale.”
Moreover, the unlawful actions were of a prolonged nature. A person who committed a crime belonging to the category of serious ones inflicted significant damage on state interests. At the court hearing the accused sincerely repented and admitted guilt, having partially compensated the damage before the start of the trial.
Subject to confiscation was real estate in the form of a house located at the address: Kingdom of Spain, city of Valencia, Avenida Virgen de la Estrella, 22, valued at 500,000 euros. The title documents were issued in the name of his spouse.
How can a corrupt official do without a villa in Spain and without a prestigious “car” — the court sanctioned the arrest also of a “Lexus LX 570,” 2016 model year, valued at 34,020,000 tenge. Although in court Chen tried to separate the “clean” money of the business from the “dirty,” proving that he acquired the villa in Spain, the apartment in Astana, and the “Lexus” before he began stealing from the Fund. Consequently, he asserted, this property was not obtained by criminal means and should not go toward compensation. The argument seemed unconvincing to the court.
Having admitted guilt immediately, without months of denial and searching for the guilty among subordinates, he began to repay the damage. By the beginning of the court process, 545 million tenge had been returned to the state.
The court found Boris Chen guilty of embezzling funds of the Fund of Compulsory Social Medical Insurance, determining five years in a colony. In addition, the remaining 137 million tenge were recovered from him. The request not to deprive him of liberty and the attempt to protect the property were not satisfied.
What Remains Behind the Scenes
This is yet another case of medical fraudsters showing the vulnerable point of the system of payment according to the fact of services: when confirmation is a line in a database, and verification is possible only after the fact, when the money has already flowed into pockets. Projects of the type of the mobile train, conceived for the treatment of people whom stationary medicine does not reach, became a feeding trough.
And why throughout all these years was there no real check capable of stopping the unjustified payments for fictitious services?
There is also another side. How and whose IINs ended up in the databases, whether these citizens knew that their data had been used, and where Chen’s employees obtained them — these questions require separate checks and discussions about the protection of personal data in medical information systems. Any mass falsifications became possible thanks to access to information about citizens who involuntarily became false patients.
This means that the end of the chain of machinations must be sought more widely and more deeply. And as other exposures in different regions have shown, these schemes with falsifications are tenacious and have become widespread in the regions. The case of Boris Chen reminds us: the most important check in the system of medical insurance is not the one that comes after the payment, but the one that stands before it.
And why in the era of comprehensive digitalization can the Ministry of Health still not defeat these falsifications? After all, all these fictitious acts with the amusing visits of men to gynecologists were signed and approved by someone higher up? Have they been punished for connivance and the absence of proper control?
We will return to this topic in the next issues of our newspaper. Because one cannot remain silent about this, for it concerns our security. And the health of the people.
Stories of fraud, large and small, keep surfacing in other regions as well. Thus, on 27 October a report appeared that the prosecutor’s office of the Akmola region achieved the return of 2.5 million tenge for illegally provided dental services to children in Stepnogorsk.
Here a dentist provided medical care to children without having the corresponding specialist certificate. Services to 345 minor patients were unjustifiably paid from the funds of Compulsory Social Medical Insurance. This cost the fund 2,569,792 tenge in paid funds.
And the point is not so much the money as how it became possible at all to allow an unqualified false specialist to provide medical care to children. Who will answer for the risks?
Akmaral ABDULOVA
Comments powered by CComment