Before moving on to the next story of doctors’ fraud, let us make a lyrical digression. The widely discussed events of the past week have shown that illegal wealth can be hidden for a time, and in a moment of danger it becomes evidence that must be gotten rid of at any cost. Thus, the money for the sake of which laws were violated turned the reputation of top managers of companies with solid backgrounds and weighty support in high offices into dust.

In any case, there is bitter irony in this. Corruption promises safety and power, but gives constant fear. The one who accumulates illegal millions lives in tension — a knock on the door turns what has been accumulated into garbage in a minute.

This story, in which many saw a staged show, made corruption visible to the ordinary person who sees neither schemes nor offshore accounts, but only its consequences. These are tax increases, rising utility tariffs, and the unrestrained growth of prices, fines, digging into benefits, and much else — the desire to extract new revenues into the budget from the already meager pockets of ordinary citizens. The contrast that caused lively discussion as a cry of the soul of people stifled by loans and mortgages, by unemployment. Public anger that cannot but be considered just. Just as the words are just: the wealth of the corrupt has come out of their necks.

How to defeat corruption? This is the question being asked today by everyone who cares about the future of the country. Although it is clear — not by spectacular footage of the capture of yet another high-ranking official, but by boring things: transparent procurements, declarations that are checked, and the inevitability of punishment for anyone, regardless of position. I do not know whether this is possible in our country and with our mentality. In a country where school and university directors steal, where any head physician can freely earn millions on falsifications.

TWO SCHEMES, AND HOW 53 MILLION TENGE LEFT THE MEDICAL INSURANCE FUND

The next criminal plot was built on the system of the guaranteed volume of free medical care, which includes prevention, diagnostics, treatment, and provision of medicines. Payment for this care is made by the non-profit joint-stock company “Fund of Social Medical Insurance,” in which deductions and contributions of the state, employers, and citizens are accumulated.

A private clinic can also become a supplier of such services: healthcare organizations, like private-practice doctors, are considered healthcare entities and conclude procurement contracts with the Fund. For the assistance provided, the clinic at the end of the month issues acts of completed work and invoice-registers, and the Fund pays them by non-cash settlement.

In Aktobe such a clinic was LLP “Medina Clinic.” From 1 January 2020 to 31 December 2025, contracts were concluded between it and the Aktobe branch of the Fund for primary medical, consultative-diagnostic care, and for preventive examinations of target groups of the population.

According to the investigation, the actual head of the clinic all these years was Zh.K. Narmukhamedov. The catch is that formally the founder was listed as his relative G.B. Sarsenova, to whom the clinic was transferred into trust management, and G.B. Dinaliyeva was appointed director. As practice showed, this arrangement allowed him to conceal his involvement in the clinic’s activities while controlling its work.

Narmukhamedov, as indicated in the case materials, had practical experience in the execution of contracts for the procurement of medical services. This experience and knowledge of how acts, registers, and checks are arranged suggested to him the idea — reports that looked lawful in form but would be fictitious in content.

SCHEME ONE: SERVICES FOR WHICH PAYMENT WAS MADE TWICE

The first mechanism is described by the prosecution as follows. Residents of the Bauyrlastar and Sazdy microdistricts, attached to polyclinics, received care at “Medina Clinic” under referrals from other medical organizations. Narmukhamedov, according to the investigation, tracked such patients and then duplicated the services already provided to them.

People’s data were entered into the “DamuMed” information system as if they had received additional services, and the Fund paid for the same care twice.

Ultrasound diagnostics of various types, consultative assistance, and other services appeared in the system. In some cases these were duplicates of actually received care; in others — falsifications, services that were not provided to patients. The clinic’s doctors, according to the investigation, knew nothing about the fact that invoices were being issued in their names and for their work.

The appointed managers also did not know: according to the prosecution, he took advantage of their incompetence in matters of compulsory social medical insurance. They were instructed only to organize the work of the clinic and to pass information about patients to him.

This scheme operated from January 2020 to December 2022. At the end of each month, acts of completed work and invoice-registers went to the Fund in the name of the clinic. The investigation counted 11,422 duplicated facts of service provision.

Employees of the Aktobe branch of the Fund, unaware of the forgery, transferred money to the clinic’s account. According to the case documents, the total amount was 27,019,573 tenge. Narmukhamedov, as the prosecution asserts, cashed these funds and spent them on his own needs.

SCHEME TWO: PART-TIME DOCTORS AND UNCONFIRMED SERVICES

According to the investigation, the matter did not end there. In parallel, from January 2020 to December 2025, acts and invoice-registers for the services of medical workers who were listed at the clinic on a part-time basis were sent to the Fund.

The prosecution counted 8,410 such unconfirmed services. The total amount of payments for them was 26,097,969 tenge.

The scenario is the same: Fund employees check the acts, see documents that are lawful in form, transfer money to the clinic’s account, and Narmukhamedov, as the investigation believes, withdraws them in cash and spends them on personal needs. The prosecution qualifies this as theft by deception and abuse of trust.

THE FINAL FIGURE

The scheme was uncovered by an unscheduled monitoring of the Aktobe branch of the Fund. Its conclusion No. 255 of 26 May 2026 records damage to the state of 53,117,542 tenge. The identified amount is qualified as damage on an especially large scale; therefore the act is regarded as fraud — the theft of another’s property by deception on an especially large scale, that is, as a criminal offense against property.

A BED FOR ONE HUNDRED MILLION

And now about the September story made public by the investigation of the Department of the Agency for Financial Monitoring in the Mangystau region, which concerned the history of the burn unit in Zhanaozen, allegedly for the purpose of helping people who had received the most severe injuries.

In 2025 the regional Health Department turned to JSC NC “KazMunayGas” with a request for sponsorship assistance to open a burn unit in the multidisciplinary city hospital. The goals were good and of substantial significance for a region where oil is extracted and production is associated with hazardous working conditions.

The request was answered: 223 million tenge was allocated — JSC “OzenMunayGas” transferred them to the public foundation “Zharylqau.” This project provided for eight types of medical equipment and the training of specialists. Then, according to the investigation, the conditions changed. Instead of comprehensive equipment, a tripartite agreement was concluded between the public foundation, the city hospital, and LLP “AKBS Invest,” as a result of which the purchase of only two anti-burn beds for 210 million tenge was provided for.

The scale of what had been conceived — to open a unit — turned into two beds, and almost the entire sum of the donation went to a single contract.

In the course of the investigation attention was drawn to the procedure itself: equipment of such cost should be procured through the Single Distributor. But the procurement was carried out in circumvention of this requirement, although this procedure exists so that the price can be verified and the supplier cannot be appointed by acquaintance.

According to the investigation, only 92 million tenge out of 223 was directed to the equipment. The rest, according to preliminary data, was cashed through affiliated enterprises and divided among the participants in the scheme.

In the chain, according to the investigation, there were four participants: the deputy director of the city hospital, the head of the public foundation “Zharylqau,” the former deputy akim of Zhanaozen, and the supplier.

Different figures, all holding positions and with their own role: the hospital accepts, the foundation distributes, the authorities assist, business supplies. Each separately could say that he was doing ordinary business. A representative of the LLP, according to the investigation, bought an apartment in the capital with the criminal proceeds and registered it in the names of third parties. Thus, money intended for burn patients turned into real estate registered to outsiders.

The case received wide public resonance. An investigation was initiated against the former deputy akim on the fact of abuse of official powers (Article 361 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan). Three suspects were placed in custody. By court sanction, property was arrested: two apartments, two residential houses, and a car.

Such is the unsightly story with charity. Sponsorship money is not budgetary, and it is not checked as closely. A public foundation as an intermediary adds a link in which it is easy to get lost. Further, the price and the necessity of the purchase remain without attention.

It seems the equipment was not stolen and the project was not disrupted. It was simply substituted: eight items turned into two, and the price grew to the size of almost the entire sum. Although outwardly the goal seems to have been achieved: the beds were purchased, the report was submitted. The relevant authorities faced the task of clarifying how much the price of the beds was inflated, who and on whose instructions changed the project conditions, and what exactly each of the participants knew. And why the planned unit suddenly turned into two beds.

FRAUD IN MEDICINE: CONSEQUENCES

Medicine is built on trust. A patient trusts a doctor with his health and life, the state and insurance companies trust a clinic with reporting, and society trusts the entire healthcare system as a whole. Falsifications and fraud undermine this trust from within. At first glance they seem a “paper” problem, but in reality their consequences are measured not only in money but also in human destinies.

The increasingly frequent facts of entering knowingly false information into documents — services that were not provided, examinations that were not conducted, bed-days that did not exist, inflated volumes of care — turn into criminal cases of fraud.

There are also such phenomena as issuing invoices for non-existent procedures, imposing unnecessary tests and operations for the sake of revenue, substituting cheap drugs with expensive ones, trading in forged certificates and sick-leave certificates. Motives vary. Some act out of self-interest. Others are forced to “draw” figures under the pressure of a plan, indicators, and financing that depends on reporting. But whatever the motive, the result is the same: official data cease to reflect reality.

And all these manipulations are a threat to the health and life of patients. For if an examination that did not take place is recorded in a patient’s chart, the doctor who will treat the person further relies on false data. An incorrect diagnosis, a missed disease, the prescription of incompatible drugs — all this can cost a life.

Akmaral ABDULOVA

Comments powered by CComment