At the basis of decision-making, including on financing issues, lies statistics. By its nature it is dispassionate, but behind the figures is a real picture that has substantial significance also in the sphere of medicine. Behind it are hidden such important aspects as the dynamics of diseases, the need for medical personnel in hospitals and medical institutions, as well as for medicinal provision. Real statistical data allow the management system to work not blindly but to see needs and cover them in a timely manner.
Of course, in real life, as it turned out, figures can easily be manipulated. In practice, in the chase after a prosperous picture, statistical reports lead away from the real state of affairs. And this aggravates pressing problems; resources are directed not to where they are acutely needed. Thus ripe questions grow into a crisis.
Such a sea of opportunities with data is provided by the Medical Insurance Fund, which has become a tool in the hands of negligent managers who “draw” unreal volumes for the payment of non-existent services and personal enrichment. Thus falsifications become the norm; doctors grow accustomed to the fact that deception can be part of everyday work. The ethical principles on which medicine should rest are eroded.
We have already written repeatedly that it is possible to combat falsifications very simply — one need only establish inevitable control, checking the validity of invoices, comparing reporting with real data. After all, with the introduction of digitalization every action of a doctor is recorded and can be verified.
But so far fraudsters have somehow managed to bypass this; therefore the scale of embezzlement dictates the necessity of tightening laws, introducing responsibility commensurate with the damage, from the return of funds to deprivation of the right to practice. Caught even once in “left movements” — be so kind as to vacate the chair and, of course, answer according to the law.
It is also necessary to change the very system of reporting and per capita financing so as not to turn the process into a financial “Klondike.” And in practice the number of the attached contingent must correspond to the real personnel and infrastructural capacities of the medical institution. As long as payment for services in healthcare is rigidly tied to volumes, there will always arise the temptation to “draw them up.”
In reality, falsifications and fraud in medicine are not a harmless violation of reporting but a threat that inflicts damage on the healthcare budget, the deficit of which ultimately negatively affects the health of the people.
Our realities are such that where big money is circulating, the concepts of “honesty” and “patriotism” no longer work.
HOW FORMAL INDICATORS TURNED INTO MONEY
If in the previous part of “Criminal Startup” the defendants in the criminal case were medics from Aktobe, now their colleagues from the city of Astana found themselves in the dock. The geography changes; the essence remains the same: financing according to the principle — the more people are attached, the more money from the Medical Insurance Fund. Petty fraud becomes major, growing into a criminal offense.
The director of LLP “Forte Clinic” Darkhan Nurlibekov performed administrative-economic and managerial functions. In the first months the activity of the clinic was conducted in good faith.
In 2022 a campaign for the attachment of the population began in it. In reality this was a little more than one and a half thousand people. This was enough to participate in the procurement of services, but the sum of the state order turned out modest.
In April 2023, being on friendly terms with an employee of the National Scientific Center for Healthcare Development Abdrakhmanov, he turned to him with a request to render assistance in the approval of applications for the attachment of the population. Thus began the “campaign” of entering knowingly false information into the medical information databases of the register of the attached population and about the provision of medical services to persons to whom such services were not actually provided.
Forming forged applications for the attachment of citizens to the LLP, the director sent them to his accomplice, who illegally approved the fictitious data. As a result the number of the attached population was artificially increased almost eightfold! 15,786 citizens were attached not through the web portal of “Electronic Government,” as required, but by written application. From April to August 2023 Nurlibekov entered into the database false information about medical services allegedly rendered to these fictitiously attached 15,786 citizens by means of access to the IS “Damu med.” The stolen funds amounted in total to 79,604,200.62 tenge.
Abdrakhmanov approved the applications, using his official position. In court he admitted that he was aware of the unlawfulness of such actions and initially refused, but subsequently yielded to Nurlibekov’s persuasions, agreeing to assist for a limited period of time. Illegal profit of 13,550,000 tenge Nurlibekov transferred from the LLP account to his personal account; 705,000 tenge went to Abdrakhmanov’s personal account. He shared, so to speak.
The guilt of the defendants was confirmed by the testimony of specialists, witnesses, the results of the Fund’s monitoring, corresponding conclusions, as well as data from healthcare information systems.
In court it was recognized that “The actions of the defendants were intentional in nature, were aimed at the illegal receipt of monetary funds of the Fund by means of fictitious attachment of the population and reflection of unreliable information about the provision of medical services, which entailed the infliction of material damage on an especially large scale. At the same time the court takes into account that Abdrakhmanov, not possessing the corresponding powers, consciously participated in the illegal approval of applications, implementing Nurlibekov’s criminal plan.”
The court sentenced Nurlibekov to five years in a colony, finding him guilty. Abdrakhmanov received about two and a half years, taking into account the application to him of the law on amnesty.
This case once again showed how easily formal indicators turn into money. And in order to stop this criminal race, something must be radically changed in the system.
In January, when the question of transferring the FSMI to the Ministry of Finance arose, the results of an IT audit of the provision of medical services were made public. According to the Ministry of Finance, the systems of the FSMI and the Ministry of Health allow billions to be written off for years on falsifications, fictitious patients, and the “anomalous” activity of doctors.
Among the identified violations: payment for thousands of attached patients of whom only half actually apply; uncharacteristic services — for example, men undergoing screening for cervical cancer; double financing — simultaneously under CSMS and voluntary employer policies; medical services to deceased citizens, including an appointment recorded 2.5 years after death; unrealistic workload norms: a doctor in Astana received 1,442 patients in one day, another — almost five thousand in a month; children to whom thousands of medications were “prescribed” per day, including 126 thousand doses of dimexide for two minors.
“A separate block of checks showed a disproportionate growth in the wealth of the heads of medical organizations: 1,465 managers bought more than five thousand real-estate objects and over 1,400 automobiles in only two years. Some — 50–120 apartments and dozens of automobiles per person.” Such is the unsightly picture.
TRAINING ABROAD OR TOURISM AT STATE EXPENSE?
Today the topic of trips at a multi-million tariff to foreign courses is also being vigorously discussed on social networks. Authors, on the basis of data from the portal of state procurements of the RK, cite examples when in the autumn of 2026 the heads of medical institutions of the Turkestan region and Astana went on attractive foreign business trips allegedly for the exchange of experience and study. It is asserted that all contracts were concluded without a tender, from a single source, with a private intermediary in the person of LLP “AE.”
Seven days, from 5 to 12 September, ten heads of medical institutions from the Turkestan region visited London. Nine paid 5.84 million tenge each; the head of the city polyclinic — 6.89 million tenge. In total almost 60 million tenge. For seven days.
From the capital seven directors went in November to Tokyo (6.69 million tenge each); two more planned a trip to Paris (5.83 million each). The total sum of the contracts is 58.48 million tenge. The authors of the comparative analysis assert that procurement of training from a single source is limited to 500 MRP, or 2.16 million tenge. Each of the contracts is almost three times higher.
Now about what benefit these trips brought. It is reported that in the database the contracts have the status “service performed,” but there are no public photo reports from the classes. And that in the program of the Paris course not a single clinic is indicated, yet meals and the cultural program are described in detail. Although ordinary nurses in the region have for years been refused even free online courses.
Recently even spicier information appeared where millions of tenge from a single source — a fly-by-night firm — will be spent on a trip. We hope the relevant authorities will take an interest in it.
So far there is no evidence that the trips gave the healthcare system anything except expenses: neither reports, nor introduced practices, nor training of those who work with patients. The choice of intermediary without a tender and the inflated price look like grounds for a check by the Supreme Audit Chamber. Heads and purchasers should publicly show the programs, reports, and the result of the training.
Of course, the exchange of experience in healthcare is needed, and it is pointless to argue with this. Medicine develops so rapidly that even a strong clinic needs new knowledge and skills. Protocols for the treatment of stroke, organization of obstetrics, work with chronic patients, digital registers: much of this has already been invented and verified in other countries. To adopt another’s successful experience is cheaper and safer than to go oneself along an untrodden road.
But the word “exchange” has a condition: there must be a real result. Study abroad is justified when a person leaves with a concrete question and returns with a concrete solution. Suppose the head of a perinatal center saw in a European clinic how the routing of women in labor is arranged, and in half a year the admission scheme changes in his center. The chief physician of a polyclinic studied the electronic appointment system and reduced queues. Such a trip can be measured: mortality decreased, waiting time shortened, trained employees passed skills on to colleagues. This is precisely the applied significance.
When this is absent, what remains is a business trip for the sake of a business trip. The signs are familiar to everyone: a program in which breakfasts and excursions are described in detail but not a single clinic is named; the absence of a public report after return; the same intermediary year after year; a price that is noticeably higher than the direct offer of another organizer. Then the exchange of experience turns into a formality, and training into a reward for the position. The money in this case is state money, and every sum spent in vain means a medicine not received, a rate not paid, or training of employees that did not take place.
The problem is especially acute against the background of inequality within the system itself. A district nurse who goes around remote auls needs training no less than a chief physician, for her work is closest to the patient. If millions are found for a week-long trip of a head, while there is neither time nor money for an online course for rank-and-file personnel, the question arises not about expenditures but about priorities. Experience should go to where it is most quickly transformed into help for people.
The solution in this is not in a ban on trips but in transparency. If the training is truly useful, it is easy to defend: publish the program and the name of the receiving clinic, show why precisely this course and precisely this intermediary were chosen, report on the results, and oblige those who returned to share knowledge with the collective. Competitive procurement, comparison of prices, and independent evaluation of the effect are needed precisely for this, and not for bureaucracy. The one who has nothing to hide only gains from such requirements.
The outcome is simple. The exchange of experience is valuable exactly insofar as it tangibly changes the work of doctors and the life of patients. If after the trip nothing has changed, then considerable sums have been spent in vain. Healthcare needs not beautiful diplomas and photographs from a cruise on the Thames, but knowledge that can be verified at the hospital bedside.
Akmaral ABDULOVA
Comments powered by CComment